« Real Humans Eat Fruit | Main | How Are Your Bones Today? »

Say Goodbye to Freedom

It's like watching a train wreck in slow motion. First George Bush packs the Supreme Court with religious conservatives, all of them promising us all along that they won't be making biased decisions. Then the cases start rolling in, each of them easily resolved from the standpoint of civil liberty: side with freedom, vote to support individuals, protect free speech, avoid repressive laws.

But nooooooooo. Our "fair" jurists have made it quite clear that their interpretation of the constitution falls heavily towards control. Can a high school kid say whatever he wants? No, not if it's a joke about Jesus and pot. Can a woman control her body? No, not if it's a type of abortion that some people find yucky. Can women sue for wage discrimination? No, not if their attempt falls outside of a narrow time window. Can taxpayers be protected from having their money spent to support religious indoctrination? No, not since Bush renamed their conversion attempts "charitable." Can individuals defend themselves from large corporations? No, the court has made it clear they're pro-business not pro-people.

When I say "the court," however, it is important to understand that while the majority rules, there are dissenting opinions. I want to thank Stevens, Souter and Ginsberg for believing that teenagers should not be silenced simply because their message makes people uncomfortable. The kid was standing on a public sidewalk with a banner reading "bong tokes 4 Jesus." His principal made him remove it and he sued, saying his freedom of speech was being curtailed. Obviously it was. But not so obviously if you're sitting on today's conservative Supreme Court who just ruled against him in a split decision.

The paradox is obvious: "no," the conservatives thunder, "you can't get an abortion because that's an individual in your belly!" But as soon as that "individual" is born, she begins losing all of her rights. Control children, control women, control employees, control dissenters. It's all happening right in front of our eyes.

And I will show you where we are headed. I belong to a community service organization in which some members recently tried to convince us that we should all say the Lord's Prayer at the end of our meetings. Obviously this would be inappropriate as we are not a religious organization nor are all of us Christians. But this didn't stop some people from arguing vociferously that they were being discriminated against if we did not agree to say their prayer. Seriously. Discriminated against.

One woman gave a canned speech which I am quite sure her church has devised to try and force all of us to adhere to its theology in the public sphere, where I quite happily exist without religion. She said that any time people excluded monotheism, they were imposing polytheism (!), thus oppressing the poor wretched monotheists. Sigh. The fact that it is those of us who do not profess christianity who are in the minority seems lost on people like her as their need to grab and retain power persists unabated. While they won't admit it, they are the enemies of freedom, clothing themselves as the opposite, torturing logic in the interests of imposing a religious agenda on a nation which was founded by people who worked adamantly to avoid just such a theocracy, having lived under one and endured its injustices.

And now they have the Supreme Court on their side.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.dianablaine.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/115

Comments

I (rather unkindly but too often truthfully) call them bible-thumping Jesus-freaks who were brain-damaged at rebirth.

These are the same people who refuse -- don't just "don't" but steadfastly refuse -- to understand how oppressive being [insert anything other than Christian here] is in the weeks between Halloween (since Thanksgiving is no longer sufficient) and about January 20.

Even in situations where folks claim that you can find your own path to god, this behavior persists. I've been to many an AA meeting sporting Christmas trees that were installed by the group, not the landlord; then when someone suggests that maybe some members might be uncomfortable with them, the reaction makes you think you should just offer a bottle of rum instead.

At this point, one can only hope that Justice Stevens survives Ann Coulter, at least until someone who has his or her mind on slightly more important things (healthcare? childcare for the working poor? education for the already-born used-to-be-fetusus?).

I'm in a similar organization and that argument has been going on for my entire 12year membership. It's not a religious organization, but you know some people don't really get that. In my group we know that the minority is just as valid as the majority. Too bad the Supreme Court doesn't operate that way.

Along with the Supreme Court, Barack Obama and John McCain are both in favor of continuing this oppressive anti-secular and anti-humanist America.

Both of them want continued federal funding of religious organizations.

Check out The Secular coalition for America Dr. D. They "get it," and they even have a lobbyist up on the hill making sure our voices are heard.

At the moment, I've decided to give this group the donations that would otherwise go to Obama's campaign.


http://www.secular.org/

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Dr. Diana Blaine - photo by Sara Pine

Dr. Diana Blaine is a PhD philosopher, writer, adventurer, bon vivant and buttkicker. She's read and studied how gender dynamics function in our culture, and here on this website, she holds forth on these issues. She's got a rich life beyond these pages;

Read More About Dr. Diana.

email Dr. Diana: diana at dianablaine dot com

dianayorkblaine's photos More of Dr. Diana's photos
-->

Recent Comments

  • miridunn on 21 Dec
  • Arianna on 14 May
  • miridunn on 21 Dec
  • miridunn on 21 Dec
  • miridunn on 21 Dec
  • Merci on 5 Dec
  • Metrojack on 4 Nov
  • raspberryjamba on 17 Nov
  • raspberryjamba on 17 Nov
  • Built by:
    Artserf Studios and Links.net
    Photo of Diana by Sara Pine
    Powered by Movable Type